As leaders, one of our most important roles is guiding our teams to grow and perform at their best. But the way we provide feedback can make all the difference between inspiring growth and shutting down confidence. At Skillsgrow, we emphasize not just the what of leadership but the how. When giving feedback, it’s crucial to do it in a way that maintains morale, encourages innovation, and promotes continuous improvement.
In this article, we’ll explore a leadership workflow that helps leaders avoid direct criticism and creates an environment where employees feel empowered to take risks, learn from mistakes, and succeed.
- Start with Praise: Acknowledge Effort
Why it matters: Starting with praise isn’t just about being polite—it’s about building afoundation of trust and positivity. Recognizing your team’s hard work lets them know that theirefforts are valued. Praise also sets the tone for constructive conversations, allowing for thecritical feedback to be received more openly.
What to say:
* “You did a great job organizing the project timeline. The team really appreciated your attention to detail.”
* “I noticed how much effort you put into preparing for the meeting today. You were well-prepared and it showed.”
What not to say:
* “I guess you did okay on the project, but it wasn’t perfect.”
* “You did some things right, but there were many mistakes.” - Avoid Direct Criticism: Guide Through Example (Use ‘And’ instead of ‘But’)
Why it matters: Direct criticism, especially when not framed carefully, can deflate a person’s confidence and lead to defensive reactions. When giving feedback, it’s important to avoid negating the praise you’ve just given. The classic “but” tends to undermine what’s been said before it. Instead, use “and” to guide the conversation forward.
What to say:
* “Your report was thorough, and next time, let’s focus on simplifying the data to make it easier for the team to understand.”
* “I liked your approach to the presentation, and in future, you could add more visual elements to make the data stand out even more.”
What not to say:
* “Your report was good, but it was too detailed.”
* “Your presentation was nice, but it needs more visuals.” - Show Confidence in Their Ability to Improve
Why it matters: Confidence is contagious. When you show belief in someone’s ability to improve, you create a culture of trust and growth. Employees who feel trusted by their leaders are more likely to take on challenges and push themselves to excel.
What to say:
* “I believe you can build on this, and with a few adjustments, you’ll make an even greater impact.”
* “I’m confident you can refine this idea to perfection with just a little more time.”
What not to say:
* “This needs a lot of work, but I guess you can figure it out.”
* “You’re going to have to work really hard to get this right.” - Encourage Future Risk-Taking
Why it matters: Great leaders don’t just want their teams to succeed—they want them to innovate. By encouraging risk-taking, you give your team the freedom to experiment, fail, learn, and ultimately grow. Fear of failure can paralyze creativity, but a leader who embraces risk sets the stage for innovative thinking.
What to say:
* “Feel free to take risks next time. Try a different approach, and we’ll see what works best.”
* “Don’t be afraid to experiment with new ideas. Even if it doesn’t work out, it will be a great learning opportunity.”
What not to say:
* “Stick with what you know. Don’t try anything too different.”
* “Be careful next time. We can’t afford to take risks.” - End on a Positive and Forward-Looking Note
Why it matters: Ending feedback on a positive note helps leave your team members feeling motivated and confident. It’s also a great way to signal that you’re invested in their future growth and that this feedback is part of a bigger picture. By offering follow-up opportunities, you create an ongoing dialogue and maintain momentum for development.
What to say:
* “I’m excited to see how you build on this. Let’s meet again in a week and discuss how it’s going.”
* “I’m confident that with a little more fine-tuning, you’ll nail it next time. Let’s check in soon to see how it’s progressing.”
What not to say:
* “This is your last chance to fix this. Do better next time.”
* “We’ll have to see if you can improve before the next meeting.”
Putting It All Together: The Feedback Workflow
- Start with Praise: Acknowledge effort and set a positive tone.
- Avoid Direct Criticism: Use “and” instead of “but” to guide the conversation.
- Show Confidence: Reinforce your belief in their ability to improve.
- Encourage Risk-Taking: Empower them to experiment and grow.
- End Positively: Finish on an encouraging, forward-focused note.
Why This Workflow Works for Leadership
As leaders, our ultimate goal is to inspire growth and performance. By following this workflow, you not only provide constructive feedback but also foster a culture of collaboration, innovation, and continuous learning. It encourages your team to see challenges as opportunities, ensuring that they feel supported in their growth journeys.
At Skillsgrow, we believe that the way leaders provide feedback is just as important as the feedback itself. When done right, feedback can be a powerful tool for team empowerment and high performance.
Takeaway for Leaders:
Feedback isn’t just about pointing out what needs improvement. It’s an opportunity to guide, inspire, and empower your team. By using this feedback workflow, you’ll create an environment where your team feels confident to take risks, learn from mistakes, and strive for excellence.
🔔 Ready to Grow Stronger Teams?
At Skillsgrow Consultancy, we help organizations develop high-performance teams through tailored training in leadership, communication, team building, and more. Whether you’re looking to empower your leaders, improve your team culture, or drive results — we’re here to support you.
👉 Let’s build better teams together.
No responses yet